Cute Cat surpasses Ballsy and Garbage Man for the all the time lead.
Brian
2002 - Duck
2003 - Lion/Pumpkin
2004 - Garbage Man
2005 - Garbage Man
2006 - Garbage Man
2007 - Freight Train
2008 - Vampire
2009 - Generic Ghost
2010 - Generic Child Named "Pat"
2011 - "Ballsy" from Wipeout!
2012 - "Ballsy" from Wipeout!
2013 - "Ballsy" from Wipeout!
2014 - Guy with a Mullet
Evelyn
2004 - Scary Witch
2005 - Care Bear
2006 - Cute Cat
2007 - Cute Cat
2008 - Butterfly
2009 - Unicorn Princess
2010 - Cowgirl
2011 - Vampire Queen
2012 - Witch
2013 - Indian Princess
2014 - Slice of Pizza
Chloe
2007 - Cute Cat
2008 - Ballerina
2009 - Ladybug
2010 - Cowgirl
2011 - Tinkerbelle
2012 - Rapunzel Wedding Princess
2013 - Non-Disney Princess
2014 - Cute Cat
Violet
2013 - Ladybug
2014 - Cute Mouse
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2002-2006